Home > Opinion > Stop the bogus Australian Vaccination Network
The "Australian Vaccination Network"
They misinform, they promote fear. They have to be stopped.
Vaccination is a marvel of medical science. An example of mankind triumphing over diseases that had previously caused millions of deaths and disabilities.
At about 94%, Australia now has one of the highest childhood vaccination rates in the world, and previously common diseases such as Polio and Measles are now almost eliminated.
But there is a dark cloud on the horizon, and that cloud is the crackpot anti-vaccination lobby, headed in Australia by the deceptively titled Australian Vaccination Network. A anti-vaccination group headed by an American woman, Meryl Dorey.
The dangers to society of groups like the AVN is devastatingly illustrated by the tragic case of 4-week old Dana McCaffery. Despite the best efforts of paramedics, doctors and an intensive care unit, Dana died of an entirely preventable disease -Whooping Cough- that she contracted before she was old enough to be vaccinated against it. The problem for little Dana was that the Northern-NSW community in which she lived has the lowest child immunisation levels in Australia, at about 64%. Her heartwrenching death was caused by the low immunisation rates in her region. Grab a box of tissues and watch the embedded video above. Further, in what could only be described as a despicable act, the McCaffreys allegedly received hate mail from AVN supporters following the initial Sunday Night story, which told Dana's story and the deadly effects of the low immunisation rates in some areas of Australia.
On their website, the AVN claim to be 'pro-choice', a promoter of unbiased vaccine information. In reality their organisation is vehemently opposed to vaccinations of any kind, and modern medicine in general. They provide no pro-vaccination information whatsoever, and they intersperse their anti-vaccination diatribe with madcap theories of government conspiracies. They scaremonger with outright lies and unsupported anecdotes of vaccination reactions with absolutely no legitimate medical evidence or data to support their extremist viewpoints. They sell T-shirts with slogans such as "Love them, Protect them, Never inject them". Their only weapon is Fear, Uncertainty and Doubt (FUD), and they use it extensively.
The AVN promote demonstrably false information, such as their inference that the current childhood DTP vaccines contain "lethal" mercury. The fact is that all childhood vaccines used in Australia since 2000 DO NOT contain mercury (thiomersal).
So why would the AVN continue to risk lives by making these outrageously false claims? Who knows, but perhaps the answer can be found from Meryl herself, who has publicly stated that we are now "living in an evil fascist dictatorship" [who are] "behind the conspiracy to cull the human population and turn the rest into little more than computer terminals", or perhaps the answer lies amongst their supporters, who claim that Doctors only vaccinate so they can get paid by the Government and that vaccination is some form of Government mind control and tracking system! The AVN recently invited Dr Archie Kalokerinos to speak at one of their seminars. He believes that vaccinations are an attempt by the World Health Organisation and the Save the Children Fund to commit genocide by spreading AIDS throughout developing countries. I kid you not.
Fortunately, the vast majority of Australians are too smart to believe the tripe being peddled by the AVN, and child vaccination rates are currently at their highest ever level. It's telling that the AVN do not list a single paediatrician or obstetrician amongst their membership, and of the 55,000 GPs across Australia, only 2 are listed as supporters of the AVN.
As their profile grows, the battle against the misinformation of the AVN is also growing. The Australian Skeptics (here and here) and the Millennium Project (here and here) have been following and exposing the crazy ideas of the AVN for a while now. Renowned Australian philanthopist and businessman Dick Smith recently took out a full page advertisement in The Australian newspaper, warning people of the deceptive practises of the AVN, and The NSW Government Heathcare Complaints Commission is currently investigating the AVN (See update below) for alleged breaches of the Public Health Act, while the Government have also refused their application for tax-deductible charity status. In 2007, the AVN were forced to issue a public apology to the Australian Medical Association, admitting that they published an article containing "a number of factual errors" in relation to vaccination. There are many blogs exposing the lies of the AVN, including this one, exposing the mistruths they published in the article Pertussis: The Fear Factor.
As if their reputation could not be further tarnished, Meryl Dorey continues to support the disgraced British Doctor Andrew Wakefield, who's debunked 1998 research was the only published study to link vaccination and Autism. In 2010, Dr Wakefield was found guilty by the British medical authorities of numerous charges dealing with medical misconduct in relation to this research, with the Medical Council ruling that he was "dishonest, irresponsible and showed callous disregard for the distress and pain of children". Yes, this is a man who is held in high regard by the AVN.
The risks of not vaccinating
If you believed the AVN, you'd be under the impression that there is little or no risk in not vaccinating your children. But according to the real medical experts, nothing could be further from the truth.
In some ways, vaccination is a victim of it's own success. It has been so effective at preventing serious disease that most people today simply have no idea about how serious and widespread these diseases were. They have never witnessed the devastation of an outbreak. This has lead to some complacency and allowed extremist groups like the AVN to appeal to the wider population.
But the risk of not vaccinating is still as large today as it was 50 years ago. The diseases are just as fatal, and there is still no effective treatment for them. A community in the Netherlands found this out the hard way when in 1992, there was a Polio outbreak within their community. 71 people were infected, with 2 dying and 59 being paralised.
And the risk doesn't just apply to your child. The lower the herd immunity, the greater the chance of an epidemic, as happened in the Dutch case above and in other isolated, unvaccinated communities.
That's why it's extremely important for adults to keep their immunisation by having boosters as required. It's estimated that even with our high child vaccination rates, there may be as little as 10% of the adult population that continue to have immunity to all the dangerous childhood diseases. The DTaP Whooping Cough vaccine, for example, may only protect you for 10 or 15 years before a booster is required. All Australians should consider visiting their GP to enquire about their immunisation levels, especially if you're currently expecting a baby or spend time around babies.
Peter Doherty AC, the Nobel Prize winning professor and immune system expert, has described the denial of childhood vaccination as a crime against humanity. Yet that is what the AVN encourage parents to do, every day.
AVN Mythbusting
The AVN say: Vaccination is not effective. Whooping cough and measels are not fatal. 12 people die every year in Australia from Measles, despite vaccination. (Yes, that's right, they have made all of these contradictory statements!)
The Truth: The table below shows just how wrong they are, on every count. In particular, take a look at the pre- and post-vaccination death toll data for Polio and Whooping Cough. It's mind-boggling. This data from the USA also unequivocally demonstrates the effectiveness of vaccination, and also dispels other myths.
The AVN say: Vaccination causes SIDS.
The Truth: The SIDS claim is particularly disturbing, considering the fear it evokes in parents. However, numerous medical studies have in fact found that vaccination drastically reduces the risk of SIDS, a point further illustrated by the fact that over the last 20 years as vaccination rates have increased, there has been a corresponding decrease in SIDS deaths. Investigating a range of studies done on the subject found that the risk of SIDS is halved in infants who have been fully vaccinated over those that have not.
The AVN say: Vaccination causes Autism.
The Truth: This oft-repeated myth of the antivax movement has been debunked by study after study, conducted all around the world. In fact, there is not a single legitimate study that has shown any link whatsoever. But you won't find links to these studies on the AVN website, because they don't want you to see them. About a decade ago, there was a single study that did theorise a link between MMR and Autism, but it has since been discredited and withdrawn. Here are links to several of the studies:
A Danish study finding vaccinated children were actually less likely to suffer from Autism than unvaccinated children.
An English study finding no change in Autism rates for vaccinated/unvaccinated children, and no change in rates before and after the introduction of vaccination.
A Japanese study finding no reduction in Autism after they withdrew the [accused] MMR vaccine in 1993.
An American study finding no change in Autism rates for vaccinated/unvaccinated children.
A Canadian study finding vaccinated children were less likely to suffer Autism than unvaccinated children.
The AVN say: Vaccination causes Polio, Shaken Baby Syndrome, Asthma, and ADHD.
The Truth: Every claim is pure rubbish. A near-endless stream of FUD from the AVN. One by one:
Polio: Clearly from the data above, this is obviously bogus. 95% of Australian children are vaccinated against Polio, and yet there hasn't been a single native case of Polio in Australia since 1978. Over 30 years of children being vaccinated, and not a single case. It's impossible for our injected Polio vaccine to cause Polio.
Shaken Baby Syndrome: Yes, I'm serious. This doozie stemmed from a violent criminal in Florida originally using the creative defence that he didn't shake his baby to death, the injuries were caused by vaccine. His defence was later changed to a claim that doctors caused the baby's death, but the anti-vaxxers are sticking to the original story.
Asthma: Another figment of the AVN's imagination, this has been debunked by a number of studies, including this British/Swiss study that actually found vaccinated children were slightly less likely to be affected by asthma.
ADHD: There is no medical study or legitimate theory that links vaccination with ADHD.
Crackpot groups such as the AVN are putting childrens lives at risk every day, and it makes my blood boil. If the AVN had it's way, Australia would be returning to the dark days of Polio, Measles, Mumps, Smallpox and many other diseases. Childhood death rates would soar to their pre-vaccination levels, and thousand of parents across Australia would experience first hand the devastating agony of burying their child. Don't let it happen.
Update 20th July 2010
The NSW Health Care Complains Commission (HCCC) have concluded their investigation into the Australian Vaccination Network. They were scathing in their assessment, revealing to the public what many parents already knew about the AVN:
"The health education service provided by the Australian Vaccination Network on its website provides misleading and inaccurate information on the subject of vaccination.
"There is evidence that the AVN misleads readers by using reliable and peer-reviewed research but quoting selectively from it, often in contradiction to the conclusions or findings of the studies themselves.
....the statements reportedly made at AVN seminars would seem to be in some cases to be grossly inaccurate"
"The AVN provides information that is misleading for the average reader by inaccurately representing information, selectively reporting information, and giving non-peer reviewed and anecdotal material the same authority as peer-reviewed literature. In all cases of misrepresentation, selective and inaccurate reporting and indiscriminate use of research material, the AVN and Ms Dorey were doing so to maintain an anti-vaccination position.
The HCCC have made the following orders:
The Australian Vaccination Network should include an appropriate statement in a prominent position on its website which states:
1. the Australian Vaccination Network's purpose is to provide information against vaccination in order to balance what it believes is the substantial amount of pro-vaccination information available elsewhere;
2. the information provided should not be read as medical advice; and
3. the decision about whether or not to vaccinate should be made in consultation with a health care provider.
While this is quite a weak sanction against the AVN, at least readers will now be aware that the AVN do not offer the accurate, balanced information that they profess.
What you can do
First, forget about trying to convince the AVN they're wrong. Anyone who thinks that the Save the Children Fund are actively engaged in child genocide is well beyond logical reasoning.
You can do your best to make sure everyone knows that the AVN is not what they appear to be. Email a link to this page to everyone you know, and join the Stop the AVN Facebook group.
The best thing you can do is get yourself a booster vaccination, particularly if you spend any time around babies or children. You can currently get a free booster if you're a new parent or regularly spend time with infants. By doing this you'll ensure that you can't pass potentially fatal diseases onto children.
Lastly, seek out accurate medical advice on vaccination for your children, which is available from your GP and the sources listed below. I cannot emphasise enough the fact that the AVN and other similar groups are not, and never have been, an accurate source of information regarding vaccination.
Meryl Dorey and the AVN must be stopped in their tracks.
It's quite literally a matter of life and death.
Comments (10)
New T-Shirt suggestion
Suggestion for an anti AVN T-Shirt:
"AVN
Hang them
Electrocute them
Never inject them"
Cheers, Prof
#1 - Prof - 08/22/2009 - 08:46
HOW YOU CAN HELP TO STOP THESE RATBAGS
This is a beautiful website. I call upon all people concerned about the AVN and Meryl Dorey to help, it is not hard. Go to Daniel's website at http://www.youngausskeptics.com/2009/08/australian-vaccination-network/ and scroll down.
Go to it!
#2 - Ken McLeod - 08/22/2009 - 11:31
Sick 'em Rex
Well done, well done.
The AVN is just another quack group preying on people's fears to support their insane conspiracy theories. If only everyone would research as well as you before they put their faith in such a group of ratbags.
May they rot in hell.
#3 - David Finlay - 08/22/2009 - 17:44
Scum of the earth
Thankyou for helping to expose the gutter slime that the AVN represent.
There is no lower form of human life than people who will deliberately lie and risk the lives of babies simply to support their anti-business, anti-government agenda.
Disgusting, despicable, filthy, bottom-dwelling slimebags. How can they live with themselves? How can anyone live in such denial?
#4 - Rebecca Simpson - 08/22/2009 - 23:24
Well done - great article
Thanks for helping expose the lunacy of the AVN. The more people that are aware of their dangerous tactics, the more lives are saved.
#5 - Daniel Raffaele - 08/23/2009 - 19:49
An excellent article, really well put together
Excellent takedown of the rabid idiotic fringe-dwellers of the AVN. A devastating summary, in fact.
Countdown until they start flooding this site with ill-informed, badly spelled comments... 3... 2... 1....
#6 - Jason Brown - 08/24/2009 - 00:01
Youre all so blind
Anyone who can read can see that those pro-vax medical studies are rigged by the Government and the companies so they show the results they want.
And all those diseases were invented in some lab by the same companies anyway. They needed to create the disease so they can then sell the vaccines.
Vaccination is nothing more than a way for corporate facists to make money and control the population and kill off anyone they don't want. I wont let them do that to my kids.
#7 - None of your business - 08/25/2009 - 19:58
Crackpots
The post above wonderfully illustrates the crackpot nature of the Anti-Vaxxers in general. It's all about conspiracies, evidence-free diatribe and fabrications.
The other common trait is the absolute avoidance of debate and the attempts to suppress the factual side of the story. A case in point is the deletion of the embedded video in this story. But try as they might, the truth is impossible to hide.
#8 - Site Admin - 08/27/2009 - 20:57
They are psychos!!
Thanks so much for writing this expose.
I've just been googling and what these psychopaths believe is incredible!. I found one antivax site that is promoting the 'fact' that vaccines contain microscopic computer chips that are activated by digital TV signals to turn people into government controlled robots! I guess they forgot to take their medication!!!
#9 - Trent Davidson - 09/13/2009 - 08:26
Jason's accurate countdown...
Jamie,
Wonderful site with factual referencing. Thank you for all of the work you have put in to make another easily accessible source to counter the loopy fear-mongering of the anti-vaccination cult. Excellent.
#10 - Peter Tierney - 11/11/2009 - 21:42
This comment form is powered by GentleSource Comment Script. It can be included in PHP or HTML files and allows visitors to leave comments on the website.
"AVN
Hang them
Electrocute them
Never inject them"
Cheers, Prof
Go to it!
The AVN is just another quack group preying on people's fears to support their insane conspiracy theories. If only everyone would research as well as you before they put their faith in such a group of ratbags.
May they rot in hell.
There is no lower form of human life than people who will deliberately lie and risk the lives of babies simply to support their anti-business, anti-government agenda.
Disgusting, despicable, filthy, bottom-dwelling slimebags. How can they live with themselves? How can anyone live in such denial?
Countdown until they start flooding this site with ill-informed, badly spelled comments... 3... 2... 1....
And all those diseases were invented in some lab by the same companies anyway. They needed to create the disease so they can then sell the vaccines.
Vaccination is nothing more than a way for corporate facists to make money and control the population and kill off anyone they don't want. I wont let them do that to my kids.
The other common trait is the absolute avoidance of debate and the attempts to suppress the factual side of the story. A case in point is the deletion of the embedded video in this story. But try as they might, the truth is impossible to hide.
I've just been googling and what these psychopaths believe is incredible!. I found one antivax site that is promoting the 'fact' that vaccines contain microscopic computer chips that are activated by digital TV signals to turn people into government controlled robots! I guess they forgot to take their medication!!!
Wonderful site with factual referencing. Thank you for all of the work you have put in to make another easily accessible source to counter the loopy fear-mongering of the anti-vaccination cult. Excellent.